Agency Relationship in Real Estate: Who Works for Whom

February 20, 2022
Written by: The Exam Scholar Team
Featured image for “Agency Relationship in Real Estate: Who Works for Whom”

This post contains affiliate links. If you buy through one of them, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.

A friendly agent at an open house greets a visitor, answers every question about the furnace, and even suggests nearby schools to check out. It feels like teamwork. However, the exam wants you to ask one cold question: does that agent work for the visitor?

Usually, the answer is no. That gap between friendliness and representation is the heart of the agency relationship in real estate.

Agency is a core topic on the national portion of the real estate salesperson exam. It also shows up in state-law questions on disclosure and representation. In fact, many of those questions really ask one thing: who is the client here?

Once you can name the client, the duties fall into place. If you can’t, however, a whole cluster of questions turns into guesswork.

Below you’ll find a clear definition, the key terms, how agency starts and ends, and one worked example. After that come common mistakes and practice questions. Fiduciary duties, dual agency and special agents each get their own posts on the site, so this one maps the whole relationship.

Online Continuing Education

Key points to remember

  • Agency exists when a principal (the client) authorizes an agent to act for them. As a result, the agent owes that client fiduciary duties.
  • The agency relationship is with the broker. Salespeople act on the broker’s behalf, so listings belong to the brokerage.
  • Clients get OLDCAR duties: obedience, loyalty, disclosure, confidentiality, accounting and reasonable care. Customers, by contrast, get honesty, fair dealing and disclosure of known material facts.
  • Agency is created by express agreement, implication, ratification or estoppel. It ends by acts of the parties or by operation of law.
  • Single agency represents one side. Dual agency, on the other hand, represents both sides with informed consent, and some states prohibit it.

What is an agency relationship in real estate?

An agency relationship is a legal relationship in which a client authorizes a licensed broker to act for them in a real estate transaction. In return, the broker takes on fiduciary duties to that client.

Think of the agent as the client’s stand-in and advocate. A lawyer in court works the same way. The lawyer argues hard for their own client and stays honest with the other side, but never argues the other side’s case.

Exam questions revolve around three parties:

  • Principal: the person who hires the agent and is represented, also called the client.
  • Agent: the broker authorized to act for the principal.
  • Third party: anyone else in the deal who is not represented by that agent, also called the customer.

Here’s the point the exam tests relentlessly. License law ties agency to the broker, not to the individual salesperson. Instead, a salesperson, or sales associate, works under the broker’s authority. That’s why a listing stays with the brokerage if the salesperson leaves.

Our post on real estate brokerage on the exam covers how that structure works.

The broker’s authority also has limits. Most real estate agents are special agents, which means they’re authorized for one specific task, such as selling one property. Therefore, they can’t sign contracts or bind the client to a deal on their own.

One correction to a common shortcut is worth making here. Single agency means the broker represents one side. In contrast, dual agency happens when the same broker or brokerage represents both buyer and seller in one transaction, not only when one individual person does.

Rules on this vary by state. Some states allow dual agency with informed consent, while others prohibit it. Still others use alternatives like designated agency.

How is an agency relationship created, and how does it end?

Agency is most often created by an express agreement, such as a listing agreement or a buyer representation agreement. It can also arise from conduct, from after-the-fact approval or from estoppel. It ends either through the parties’ actions or automatically by law.

First, two definitions. A fiduciary is a person in a position of trust who must put the client’s interests ahead of their own. OLDCAR summarizes those duties, and our dedicated OLDCAR post breaks them down one by one.

Next, the client versus customer split. A customer is someone the agent works with but doesn’t represent. A customer becomes a client when the agency relationship forms, usually when an agreement is signed.

However, “usually” is doing real work in that sentence. Agency can legally arise without a signature, and the exam knows it.

Four ways agency is created

  • Express: the parties state the agency in words, such as a signed listing agreement.
  • Implied: an agent acts as a buyer’s advocate and the buyer reasonably relies on it, even with nothing signed.
  • Ratification: a principal approves, after the fact, actions taken without prior authority, such as accepting an offer an unauthorized licensee presented.
  • Estoppel: a principal leads a third party to believe someone is their agent, so the principal can’t later deny it.

Even so, a written agreement remains the clearest proof. In most states, a broker also needs one to enforce a commission claim. For the details of each contract type, see our guide to buyer and listing agency agreements.

How agency ends

Termination falls into two groups. The first group covers endings by the parties:

  • Performance, meaning the deal closes
  • Expiration of the agreement’s term
  • Mutual agreement to cancel
  • Revocation by the principal
  • Renunciation by the agent

Note that a principal can usually revoke, but doing so may still create liability for damages or a commission under the contract. The second group is termination by operation of law. In that case, agency ends with the death or incapacity of either party, destruction of the property, bankruptcy, or loss of the broker’s license.

Here’s a memory aid: the job got done, the clock ran out, someone walked away, or the law stepped in. Together, those four phrases cover performance, expiration, revocation, renunciation or mutual agreement, and the legal triggers.

How does an agency relationship work in a real transaction?

The fastest way to learn how an agency relationship in real estate works is to follow one deal from first contact to closing. At each step, name the client, the customer and the duties owed.

Step 1: The listing

Maria lists her house with ABC Realty and signs an exclusive right-to-sell listing. The principal is Maria, and the agent is ABC Realty’s broker.

Meanwhile, Dev, the ABC salesperson who handles the listing, acts on the broker’s behalf. So if Dev quits next month, Maria’s listing stays with ABC.

Step 2: The open house

Jordan, a buyer with no agent, visits Dev’s open house. Jordan is a customer. Accordingly, Dev must be honest and disclose known material facts as state law requires.

Still, Dev owes Jordan no loyalty and no confidentiality. In other words, anything Jordan says about his budget can go straight to Maria.

Step 3: The moment a customer becomes a client

Jordan then signs a buyer representation agreement with XYZ Realty. Now he is a client of XYZ, and XYZ owes him fiduciary duties. Notice the shift: Jordan can now safely share his budget strategy with his own agent instead of with Dev.

Step 4: The dual agency variation

Suppose Jordan wanted to sign with ABC Realty instead. ABC would then represent both sides, which is dual agency, even if a different ABC salesperson worked with Jordan.

Where it’s allowed, it requires informed written consent from both parties. Where it’s prohibited, however, ABC would have to decline or keep Jordan as a customer.

Step 5: Closing

The deal closes, the purpose is complete, and the agency ends by performance. However, confidentiality about Maria’s finances continues after closing. Exam writers love that detail.

Common mistakes

  • Thinking the salesperson owns the agency. The client’s relationship is with the broker. So reject answers saying the listing “belongs to the agent.”
  • Treating friendliness as representation. Test writers describe a warm, helpful agent to bait you. Remember, helpful is not loyal.
  • Assuming no signature means no agency. Implied agency, ratification and estoppel create duties without one.
  • Mixing up payment and representation. Who pays the commission doesn’t decide the client. Instead, the agreement does.
  • Forgetting surviving duties. Confidentiality outlasts closing.
  • Using another state’s rules. Answer dual, designated and transaction broker questions with your own state’s law.

From experience

One way the Exam Scholar team teaches this topic is the “whose pocket is the agent’s phone in?” test. Picture the agent’s phone ringing in the middle of a negotiation. Whoever the agent is legally obligated to call first with that news is the client. Everyone else is a customer.

Now run the open-house scenario through it. Jordan, chatting with Dev, mentions he could stretch his budget well past his opening offer. Who does Dev call? Maria, the seller.

That’s because Dev’s duty of disclosure runs to his client, so the information belongs in Maria’s pocket, not Jordan’s. For that reason, a careful agent would ideally warn an unrepresented visitor about this before the visitor starts sharing.

The image works because it turns an abstract legal question into a concrete one. Under exam pressure, “who does the agent owe fiduciary duties to?” can blur. By contrast, “who gets the phone call?” rarely does.

Practice questions

Question 1: Client or customer?

Show answer

A salesperson holding an open house for a seller is approached by an unrepresented buyer who asks for advice on how low to offer. In this situation, the buyer is best described as the salesperson’s: A) client, B) customer, C) principal, D) subagent.

Answer: B) customer. The agency relationship is with the seller, so the seller is the principal and client. As a result, the buyer is a third party, owed honesty and required disclosures but not advocacy. A and C describe the seller, while D describes a licensee working on the seller’s broker’s behalf, which the buyer is not.

Question 2: How was the agency created?

Show answer

Without any agreement, a licensee presents an offer to a property owner on behalf of a buyer and negotiates terms. The owner then accepts the offer and agrees to pay the licensee’s commission. Agency was created by: A) express agreement, B) ratification, C) estoppel, D) implied agency.

Answer: B) ratification. Ratification is when a principal approves, after the fact, actions taken without prior authority. Since there was no prior agreement, A is wrong. Likewise, estoppel involves a principal misleading a third party about who their agent is, which didn’t happen.

Finally, the owner’s approval after the fact is the defining event. That points to ratification rather than D.

Question 3: When does agency end?

Show answer

A listing agreement has three months remaining when the seller dies. What happens to the agency relationship? A) It continues until the listing expires, B) It transfers to the seller’s heirs, C) It terminates by operation of law, D) It is suspended until the estate is settled.

Answer: C) It terminates by operation of law. The death or incapacity of either the principal or the agent ends the agency automatically. Consequently, the heirs or the estate would need to sign a new agreement. A, B and D all assume the relationship survives the principal’s death, and it doesn’t.

What to study next

An agency relationship in real estate is a principal authorizing a broker to act on their behalf. This creates fiduciary duties to that client but not to customers. So once you know how agency is created and ended, you can answer most agency questions by first naming the client.

Next, review OLDCAR for the duties themselves, and then check your state’s dual agency rules. After that, read up on broker supervision and responsibility to see why the broker carries the agency.

If you’re still finishing your pre-licensing hours, CE Shop offers self-paced, state-approved courses that work on a phone or computer. Then, when you’re ready, take an Exam Scholar real estate practice test. The readiness meter will show whether agency needs another pass before exam day.


Share: